The letter from your customer’s supplier quality engineer says Controlled Shipping Level 1. Or Level 2, with a third-party inspector your plant pays for. Every affected part now gets an extra inspection before it ships. The plant manager wants to know how long this lasts. The customer wants a root cause and a plan.
This guide is for the plant or division Quality Director who has to get the plant out. It covers what CS1 and CS2 mean, the first 48 hours, the exit criteria, the daily cost, the exit request and how to stay out.
The short version
- Start the sort today. Get the exit criteria from the customer in writing.
- Find why the defect happened and why your controls let it ship.
- Update the PFMEA, control plan, process flow and work instructions before you ask to exit.
- Show the plant manager the daily cost, built from your own records.
- Carry the fix to every line and plant with the same cause.
What CS1 and CS2 Mean
Controlled shipping is a formal demand from your customer for an extra inspection on top of your normal controls, until you fix the cause. In Level 1 your own people inspect. Level 2 adds a third party, paid by the supplier.
- CS1. Your people sort the affected parts at your plant, in a containment area apart from production, and report the results.
- CS2. CS1 plus a 2nd inspection by a third party the customer approves, at the supplier’s cost. Some customers want it outside your plant, others at your plant and theirs.
- Timing and notice. Each customer sets its own. PACCAR’s supplier quality manual, for example, asks for CS1 within 1 hour of notice and CS2 within 24 hours. It also asks for a notice to your certification body within 5 business days of entering CS2.
Work from your customer’s supplier manual and the letter itself, not from a general guide.
First 48 Hours: Contain and Get the Exit Criteria
Start the sort before the analysis. Then get every rule of the status on paper.
- Answer the letter in writing. Confirm the parts, the defect, the inspection method and the reporting format.
- Set up containment. Apart from production, well lit, with boundary samples, instructions and qualified gauges. Mark every inspected container.
- Set the breakpoint. Find the first good lot and trace every suspect part, in your plant, in transit and at the customer.
- For CS2, book the third party. Issue the purchase order and hand over the drawing, the instructions and the gauges.
- Get the exit criteria in writing. Ask for each one: the clean period, the data, the documents and who signs the exit. If the letter does not list them, ask before day 2 ends.
In controlled shipping now?
Get the exit packet checklist: what your customer needs to see before lifting it, in the order they review it.
We email you the PDF. No newsletter. Privacy policy
Week 1: Find Why It Shipped
Answer 2 questions: why the defect happened, and why your controls let it ship. The customer will ask for both.
- Occurrence. Open the PFMEA row for the operation. Check that the cause was listed and the prevention control was real.
- Detection. Find the control that should have caught it: the control plan line, the gauge, the reaction plan.
- A missing row. If no PFMEA row predicted this failure, add the row and rate it.
- A design cause. A tolerance the process cannot hold, or a characteristic never marked as special, starts in the DFMEA.
- A machine cause. A worn tool, a drifting fixture or a failed sensor belongs in the PFMEA and in the machine’s maintenance tasks.
Sort the containment data by shift, machine, cavity and lot to narrow the cause. Then verify it: switch the cause on and off and watch the defect follow.
What the Customer Needs to See to Exit
The customer’s written criteria decide. A typical list has 4 parts.
- A verified root cause. The cause, how you found it and how you proved it.
- Corrective actions that hold. Error-proofing, a changed tool or a changed process, not a reminder to operators.
- Updated documents. PFMEA, control plan, process flow and work instructions, revised and dated.
- A clean period. Zero defects found in containment for the period the customer sets, on a run chart from day 1.
Nexteer’s published supplier containment instruction is a clear example. It asks for containment data that shows the new controls work and a verified root cause. It also wants copies or excerpts of the revised control plan, FMEAs, flow diagram and operator instructions.
Make the Daily Cost Visible
Show the plant manager what each day in controlled shipping costs, from your own records. Do not estimate a total. Add up real lines every day.
- Third-party inspection: invoiced hours × the contract rate.
- Your own sorting: inspector hours × your loaded labor rate.
- Parts: scrap and rework from the sort.
- Logistics: premium freight and the floor space the sort takes.
- Engineering: hours on the 8D, the test runs and the document updates.
- Customer charges: whatever your contract lets the customer charge back.
Ask finance for the rates once. Then add 1 line to the containment board: cost yesterday, cost to date, days in status. Review it daily with the plant manager. Then there is the cost no invoice shows: a supplier that keeps failing containment can be escalated to a new business hold.
The Exit Request
Ask to exit only when every criterion is met. Give each criterion its own section, with the evidence beside it.
- The criteria as the customer wrote them, each with its evidence.
- The containment run chart, from the 1st day to today.
- The root cause, how you verified it, and each corrective action with its date.
- The revised PFMEA, control plan, process flow and work instructions, with matching revision levels.
Say what stays in place after exit. Expect a written answer. Some customers move a supplier from CS2 to CS1 before they release it.
What to Tell the Plant Manager and the Customer
Both want 4 lines: what failed, why it shipped, what changed, and when you expect to meet the exit criteria. The plant manager also wants the cost to date and the cost per day. Send the update on the same day each week. Do not promise an exit date before the root cause is verified.
Prevent Re-Entry
The same cause on another line, part or plant can put you back in. PACCAR’s manual, for example, counts the same root cause on any part, from any of the supplier’s locations, within 2 years of the corrective action as a repeat.
- Read across. Check every PFMEA that shares the operation, the machine or the material.
- Keep the new detection control until the data shows the cause is gone.
- Close the loop. Every 8D and complaint lands in the PFMEA row it belongs to, not in a folder.
- Review when the evidence changes, not only once a year.
See why the same 8D keeps coming back.
How Tacit AI Approaches This
Tacit AI builds the full DFMEA, PFMEA and control plan from your own drawings, process flows, test results, 8Ds and failure reports, to AIAG-VDA, with every row traced to its source. It imports your 8Ds, complaints and NCRs and links each record to the FMEA row it belongs to. Gap detection proposes a new row when a failure appears that no row predicted. Regression detection flags a control that failed again. Engineers review and approve every change. It works on top of the FMEA tool you already run.
A Top 20 Global OEM builds FMEAs 8× faster with it, with 26% fewer actions after customer review.
If you are in controlled shipping now, book a working session and bring the 8D and the PFMEA for the operation in containment. See also how to link 8Ds to the PFMEA and keeping the PFMEA and control plan aligned.
In controlled shipping now?
Get the exit packet checklist: what your customer needs to see before lifting it, in the order they review it.
We email you the PDF. No newsletter. Privacy policy
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between CS1 and CS2?
In CS1 your own people run an extra inspection at your plant. CS2 adds a 2nd inspection by a third party the customer approves, paid by the supplier. The details differ by customer.
Who pays for controlled shipping level 2?
The supplier. It issues the purchase order to the third party and pays its costs. If it does not start in time, some customers set up the containment themselves and charge it back.
How long does controlled shipping last?
Until you meet the exit criteria and the customer confirms the exit in writing. The customer sets the clean period. Ask for it in writing on day 1.
Do I have to tell my certification body about CS2?
Some customers require it. PACCAR, for example, asks suppliers to notify their certification body within 5 business days of entering CS2. Check your customer’s requirements.
What documents should change before I ask to exit?
The PFMEA, control plan, process flow and work instructions for the affected operation, plus the DFMEA if the cause sits in design. Expect the customer to ask for a copy of each revised document.